Obligations vs Rights
In light of active citizenship initiatives taking place across the country and the National Planning Commissions Strategic Plan, the relationship between obligations and rights has been playing on mind a lot. More so, in terms of how to use the one to strengthen the other and also the fundamental of the nature of this relationship between the two.
From this an important question for me is: Why do the apparent ‘entitlement syndromes’ lingering in society slants towards rights as opposed to obligations in order to enjoy those desired rights?
Literally by chance and like an answer to my ponderings, I bumped into a Book Review of a book by T.R. Reid titled, “Confucius lives next door: What living in the East teaches us about living in the West.” The teachings of the Chinese philosopher Confucius (551 – 479 BC) are usually presented as a philosophy about social harmony over state control, where societies live in harmony and stability in a two way yin and yang flow of duties and responsibilities.
The people’s duty to work towards the development of the state would be balanced by the government’s duty to care for the people and to provide for their welfare. A Confucian individual is thus one who is born into obligations, as opposed to their Western counterpart, who is born with rights. In essence what this translates to is that the former is bound by rites, while the later is protected by rights.
‘Confucius says:’ if everyone had morality, they would not need to be governed. This may help to explain the importance of the role of the state, family and community in the South African development context. What I have learned the most out of the bit of reading I have done from and on Confucius is that there is a huge need in South Africa to transfer greater responsibility to individuals and society, mobilising the population in a greater development effort.
In future it would be great to see a society performing its obligations towards and for each other rather than demanding its rights from each other.






